TAWTICS’ Absolutely Timely and Completely In Depth Look at the 89th Academy Awards

See the joke is that the Oscars were like two weeks ago. And considering that I only saw a handful of the films nominated, I wasn’t going to comment at all, let alone what little commentary I have. And yet I do have some opinions on a couple Oscar-related things, so, as a film connoisseur, I am inclined to say something. (But again, full disclosure, I did not see all the films, as much as I would have liked to, so some commentary may be a bit skimpy).

  • Original Screenplay: Manchester by the Sea— So I didn’t see Manchester by the Sea. Frankly I don’t even know anything about it now. But still as an aspiring screenwriter, I do love a good screenplay. Maybe I’ll check this one out, see if I feel the writing is authentic.
  • Adapted Screenplay: Moonlight— So I’m definitely checking out Moonlight in the future for reasons I will disclose later (though it’s probably obvious). But I did not know that it was an adapted screenplay. In fact I found out that this movie was adapted from the play, In Moonlight Black Boys Look Blue, by Tarell Alvin McCraney which… I don’t know, personally I don’t think I’ve ever seen such a transition. As such, however, I’m even more interested in watching either medium to see what the format does to the story and how it is presented. Should be cool.
  • Visual Effects: The Jungle Book— Tough category. I mean The Jungle Book was up against Dr. Strange and Rogue One: A Star Wars Story which were some great films in terms of the integration of live action and CG effects. Still though, from what I saw in promotional material, The Jungle Book‘s use of visual effects looked pretty rad as well. Props to them.
  • Short Film (Animated): Piper— So for this category I saw Piper and Borrowed Time, mainly because those were the ones I saw pop up on my social media feed a lot. Who would’ve thought that internet virality may help in an animated short’s popularity? (The answer is most people, I think). Still though, I think this is well deserved for Piper. Fantastic animation, a lovable bird protagonist, and overall a cute story. Shout out to Borrowed Time though, because I’m a sucker for people perverting the idea that animated movies have to be all sunshine rainbows where nothing realistically upsetting happens.
  • Production Design: La La Land— Alright then. I can dig it. As one of the only academy award nominated films that I actually saw (and enjoyed), I can respect this. Overall I felt that La La Land had very striking and emotionally inspiring art direction that worked well for the mood it was going for. However I will recognize Hail, Caeser! and Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, because even though I thought they were just alright movies, their visuals were pretty solid.
  • Original Song: “City of Stars” from La La Land music by Justin Hurwitz and lyrics by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul– My god! Be still my beating heart. “City of Stars” is a fantastic song. I could say that about any of the music from La La Land, especially for also nominated song “Auditions (The Fools Who Dream),” but I am glad that this beautiful love song won. Still though, I am conflicted considering that “How Far I’ll Go” from Moana was also nominated. I guess I’ll just base my impression of which I liked more on what I listened to more after I had seen either film.
  • Original Score: La La Land— Again another one for La La Land. Though I had not seen any of the other nominations (I’m sure their scores were also fantastic), I feel that if a musical fails to get this award, there’s a problem. Overall I liked the score of La La Land both with the ballads and jazz, and I think it really added to the narrative that was presented.
  • Makeup & Hair Styling: Suicide Squad— Okay I’ll be honest. Nothing else matters more with this Academy Awards than this Oscar pick. But now we have to face it. Suicide Squad is an Oscar winning movie. Suicide Squad. You know? The movie with 26% on Rotten Tomatoes? I sorry, but I just find this award win to be rather ridiculous on two accounts. One, it beat Star Trek Beyond, which honestly has some of the best makeup work out there. I mean how else did they make such rad aliens? We are talking about a comparison between a pink alien with a head that has extending crab legs and writing “damaged” on someone’s forehead. And secondly, I think it’s more the implication that such a horrid movie can now say in its marketing that it is an academy award winning movie that I find… problematic. Definitely the biggest upset of the Oscars for me this year (and that’s saying something considering they fucked up giving out the Best Picture award).
  • Film Editing: Hacksaw Ridge— I haven’t seen Hacksaw Ridge (like most of these films), but damn this must have been a hard choice considering the other runners for the award. I mean I guess at the end of the day I just gotta see how good Hacksaw Ridge really is in that department. Maybe expect a review of it in the not so distant future.
  • Directing: La La Land— Again another tough choice. Virtually the same selection that the Film Editing award had, and virtually the same level of “god I need to watch these films to get a better understanding of direction.” Honestly though I’m pretty null when it comes to directing choices unless they’re really obvious or unless they really floor me. I know. It’s a pretty wide net I’m casting with that criteria. But I will say that from what I recall, La La Land was pretty well directed by Damien Chazelle. Lot of good choices behind that camera.
  • Costume Design: Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them— Alright then. I’ll accept this one. If I’m being quite frank, I did not fully enjoy Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. I thought it was just alright, and should have had less screen time for emo religious children, and more of the beasts and the wizarding world of America. However, I find the costuming to be rather, dare I say, fantastic. It was more than just period piece clothing (as in what was mostly represented in Jackie) and did more by way of meaning and character building than the bright colors and expressive clothes of La La Land. As to how Fantastic Beasts‘ costumes stack up to Allied and Florence Foster Jenkins, I cannot say. But still I think I’ll at least give the newest in the Harry Potter world this much credit.
  • Cinematography: La La Land— Again we have a selection that I’m not too familiar with. Like I get the gist of what cinematography is, but I can’t really tell you what is and is not good by way of it (here’s to hoping that I learn more about it throughout this whole process). Still, what’s going on in front of the camera in La La Land is pretty and purposeful. It truly helps solidify the moods of certain parts of the movie and it adds a measure of character development and understanding that we think subconsciously while watching. Still though, I’ll have to check out the other selections for this category to get a broader understanding of cinematography.
  • Animated Feature Film: Zootopia— Wow! What a selection! I’m sorry but this is just an impossible choice for me let alone an impossible choice for the academy. Zootopia was against Kubo and the Two StringsMoanaThe Red Turtle, and even though I didn’t see it, it was still probably just as good, My Life as a Zucchini. How do you even pick between strong animations, amazing storytelling, and lovely music? Still though, I think what separates Zootopia from the rest is its message. A timely and poignant film, I’m just glad that there was a “children’s movie” (and I really hate describing these films as such on account of their wide appeal) out there that talks about what Zootopia talks about. That I find is it’s truly outstanding feature making it worth this award over all these other wonderful films.
  • Supporting Actress: Viola Davis, Fences— Another good pick here. Viola Davis is a wonderful actress, and so I’ve been told, she’s a wonderful complement to Denzel Washington in Fences. As for the other actresses go in this category go, I’m sure they did excellent as well, but as always I didn’t see their movies, so I’m just going off of past performances and victories/nominations. Still though, lovely to see Viola Davis finally win one of these awards. I know she’s only had three nominations, but she’s earned the win after those three. And now here’s to hoping that she drops a sick album soon so she can get an EGOT. So damn close!
  • Supporting Actor: Mahershala Ali, Moonlight— Hell fuckin’ yes! I love Mahershala Ali. I loved him in Luke Cage. I loved him in House of Cards. And hell it’s been a while since I’ve seen The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, but Mahershala Ali’s in that as well, and he probably nailed it too. A phenomenal actor, and well deserving of this Oscar. However, as my standard disclaimer goes, I did not see Moonlight or really any of the other nominations for this award. Everyone else is probably just as deserving. But fuck that standard disclaimer! Mahershala rules. And in addition, I just find it rather exceptional (if not a little disappointing with how long it took), that Ali is the first Muslim actor to win an Oscar. Well played on this choice, academy.
  • Leading Actress: Emma Stone, La La Land— I’m both pleased and upset with this choice. I’m pleased because one, I did love Emma Stone as the hopeless Hollywood dreamer type. She was funny and believable and made my heart hurt a bit. And two, I’m just happy that Meryl Streep didn’t get her 5,000 Oscar in a leading actress role. I love her and really she deserved those other Oscars she won, but I need a little spice in the selection of winners here. But then in terms of my displeasure, there were two more things. One, I just really like Natalie Portman and Ruth Negga. I was really holding out for them to win something for their amazing portrayals of Jackie Kennedy and Mildred Loving (two ladies of historical importance). And then the second thing is that I didn’t really think Emma Stone had a super impressive/transformative performance as Mia. To me it just seemed like Emma Stone was playing another version of herself or her other typical roles. Again I won’t say that I didn’t like her role as Mia (or any of her previous roles for that matter), I just wanted something a little different from the norm in my leading actors/actresses
  • Leading Actor: Casey Affleck, Manchester by the Sea— Wow… what a hot button issue here. It’s not every day that a famous person with sexual assault allegation gets a medal… Oh wait. Honestly, I’m usually pro-talent when it comes to these kinds of issues. Like when actors have snafus come out about them through some tabloid or something, if it’s not that serious I can forgive for the sake of “the best at the job wins.” This is not one of those situations. Like really anyone else nominated for this award could’ve/should’ve won it. I mean Christ, he was only up against Ryan Gosling, Andrew Garfield, Viggo Mortensen, and Denzel Washington. And look, say what you will about any of those performances in terms of quality (I didn’t see Fences, though I’ve heard that Denzel Washington did a transcendent performance), but really I think any of these other options would have been way less controversial than Casey “Sexual Assault Allegation” Affleck, while still maintaining a level of quality.
  • Best Picture: Moonlight— Aw yes. The big whammy. The movie that almost didn’t get it’s Oscar, Moonlight. Look for my comments one the whole switcheroo debacle, it’s simply… someone fucked up. Whoever is in charge of getting the envelopes to the award presenters, whoever is back stage keeping tabs on those things, they made a mistake. But in the grand scheme, at least they corrected it. The La La Land crew could have easily left with their Oscars, thereby fully snubbing Moonlight. But the producers of the event found out and, as seamlessly and quickly as they could, rectified the situation. Was it awkward? You bet. But it was just a mistake. What I don’t agree with is the notion that people believe this mix up was done to take steam away from Moonlight‘s win. While that has been the unfortunate result of the event, as I’ve seen in a lot of media about the whole event, I don’t believe that there was foul play that caused it. Just a genuine mistake. Let’s not repeat it again. Cause otherwise we risk throwing salt at an excellent movie like Moonlight. Now again… I did not see Moonlight. And even though it was stacked up against La La Land (near and dear to my broken heart), I find that given the subject matter of Moonlight it deserved to be brought to attention. Solid win for them, and again really can’t wait to watch it.

* Retracted from this list were Sound Mixing, Sound Editing, Foreign Language Film, Short Documentary, and Feature Documentary because I really had nothing on them at all. Some of those awards I just didn’t understand enough and others I literally saw none of the nominations so…